OEE (overall equipment effectiveness) measures how well a machine or line runs during the time it’s scheduled to run. TEEP (total effective equipment performance) measures the same thing against every hour in the calendar, so it shows how much capacity you have before you buy equipment or add a shift. OPE (overall production effectiveness) widens OEE to include the manual steps and non-machine time around the line. Most plants should run their lines on OEE and use TEEP to decide whether they need more equipment or more shifts. (Outside manufacturing, OPE usually means something else, such as out-of-pocket expenses. This article covers the manufacturing metric.)
What’s the difference between OEE vs. OPE vs. TEEP metrics in manufacturing? It’s a question I hear a lot. They’re metrics that are used often, but each is a different method of determining the availability of a production line. Essentially, they help manufacturers understand how many goods they can produce versus how many they are actually producing. All three metrics look at performance, availability, and quality.
- Below, I’ll get into the difference between OEE vs. OPE and OEE vs. TEEP and highlight the advantages of tracking both.
- In my synopsis, I’ll also add in a different metric/measurement that is actually proving to be preferred by top manufacturing executives and business leaders.
What is OEE (overall equipment effectiveness)?
OEE stands for Overall Equipment Effectiveness. We go into more detail about what OEE is and what it’s not here. OEE is a metric used to calculate and score all the elements of machine effectiveness in the manufacturing process. It combines availability, performance and quality into one score. Utilization isn’t part of OEE; it’s what TEEP adds. It is supposed to summarize the efficiency of a machine, cell, or production line during the manufacturing process.
Many manufacturers view it as an important metric to optimize around; however, we’ve talked before about some of the nuances that come with this metric that must be explored before it can be used as a true rubric for process and product improvement. (And, some even debate the role scheduled downtime plays in calculating OEE.) You can use a free OEE calculator here and calculate OEE yourself.
For a full explanation of each component, see our guide to overall equipment effectiveness.
What is OPE (overall production effectiveness)?
OPE stands for overall production effectiveness. It is not the same as TEEP. OPE keeps the OEE structure but counts the whole production process, including manual steps and time when a machine isn’t scheduled to run. There is no single standard OPE formula, so define it in writing before you compare sites.
The biggest difference between OPE and OEE is that OPE includes disconnected elements that may not be included in OEE calculations. This means that it includes things like the time when a machine is not scheduled to run and activities like selective procedures and manual processes that don’t include the machines themselves or may not apply to every product in a production run. OPE will also commonly include planned downtime in the calculation as we mentioned above. This is not usually calculated in OEE. Typically, employees must collect the data for the OPE calculation manually; as this is the point of the calculation. It captures processes that are not often easily measured by a sensor or machine and must have planned downtime inserted into the data.
As a next step, manufacturers concerned with OPE generally want to enter this information into some kind of database or analytics system to analyze the data more quickly and efficiently.
For a closer look at how manufacturers use OPE, read Understanding OPE in the manufacturing industry.
What is TEEP (total effective equipment performance)?
TEEP measures the share of all calendar time (24 hours a day, 7 days a week) that a line spends making good parts at full speed. It answers a different question from OEE: not how well you use the time you schedule, but how much time you leave on the table.
“What is the difference between TEEP and OPE, though?” TEEP measures the percentage of the total time that is productive. TEEP goes one step further than OEE by evaluating the potential of a plant – how much capacity a manufacturer has to produce without having to buy new equipment.
OEE, TEEP and OPE formulas, with a worked example
- OEE = availability × performance × quality
- TEEP = OEE × utilization, where utilization = planned production time ÷ all calendar time
- OPE = the OEE formula, with availability counted against the time the whole production process is staffed, not only machine time
Worked example: a line is scheduled for two 8-hour shifts, 16 of 24 hours, so utilization is 67%. If its OEE over those shifts is 60%, its TEEP is 60% × 67% = 40%. The line is good for 40% of the hours in the week. That gap is the capacity a third shift or weekend run could reach before you buy another line. Check your own numbers with the OEE calculator.
TEEP vs OEE: when to use each
Use OEE to run the line: it tells supervisors how well the scheduled time went, shift by shift, and which loss to fix first (downtime, slow cycles or scrap). Use TEEP to plan capacity: it tells the plant manager and finance whether the answer to more demand is another shift or another machine. A high OEE with a low TEEP means the line runs well but sits idle much of the week. A low OEE means fix the line before you add hours to it.
What is OOE?
While we haven’t really talked about this metric, OOE (Overall Operations Effectiveness) is worth mentioning. OOE measures the availability of all operations from start to finish, including things like planned maintenance.
To calculate OOE, you would use the same formula as OEE, but the primary difference would be how you determine availability. You would include actual production time/ uptime in the OOE formula whereas OEE only includes scheduled time.
OOE is good to understand, but it’s rarely used to judge production availability.
OEE vs OPE vs TEEP: which is better?
It always comes down to finding the right tool for the right job. When applied to the right business and the right problem correctly, all three metrics offer benefits to manufacturers.
For example, Nulogy tracks OEE automatically and gives you the availability and run-time data to work out TEEP.
OEE is an industry standard across a lot of major industries. Theoretically, it is a very objective metric with a uniform set of criteria that allows manufacturers to improve their efficiency by using it as a measuring stick vs. previous calculations.
The biggest drawback of optimizing around OEE is that the number itself isn’t all that important. Often, manufacturing employees will fudge the numbers or run calculations so that they can maintain an industry acceptable OEE number.
It’s far more important for manufacturers to establish a true OEE metric for their business and then work to determine what factors are most important for them to optimize or improve based on accurate data.
What OPE adds to OEE
All the caveats about OEE also apply to OPE; however, OPE offers some additional benefits as a calculation to manufacturers that are accurately collecting and analyzing things like planned downtime and other manual processes. It simply provides some additional context.
With either metric, context really is what manufacturers should be seeking. Both metrics are meant to provide an objective snapshot of how efficiently the manufacturing production line, cell, or machine is operating. If the data is good, the measurement should really just be providing a point to compare and improve upon.
Overall factory efficiency: what to measure first
Truthfully, there is nothing wrong with choosing to believe in OEE vs. OPE as gospel, or choosing to completely ignore these metrics. I’ve heard manufacturers on both sides of the fence make a good case.
Ultimately, it is about the visibility on their factory floor that a manufacturer has that determines how helpful either metric will or won’t be.
The manufacturers that do the best job of improving their overall manufacturing productivity and efficiency are the ones with the best data and the clearest picture of what is actively influencing things like quality and availability.
I write a lot about visibility and honestly believe it is a far better idea to work towards than obsessing over which metric to use and what the ultimate score is.
Again, you can measure both metrics easily with a tool like Nulogy Smart Factory — purpose-built OEE software. It will also provide the visibility needed to properly improve the variables responsible for the culmination of both metrics.
Hopefully, that provides some insight into this topic.
Nulogy Smart Factory is purpose-built OEE tracking software that tracks OEE automatically and gives you the availability and run-time data to work out TEEP — giving manufacturers the real-time visibility they need to move from metric collection to continuous improvement.
Louisiana Fish Fry raised OEE 12% in nine months on Nulogy Smart Factory (read the Louisiana Fish Fry story).
To see OEE tracked live on your own lines, book a Smart Factory demo.